Wednesday, June 6, 2012

Industry, Medicine and Medical Ethics

This morning I co-chaired a meeting of the Massachusetts Association of Health Plans (MAHP) Ethics Forum that used the Massachusetts Gift Ban law as an entry point for discussing the relationship between the medical products industry and the medical profession.

Marcia Hams, program director of the Community Catalyst Prescription Access and Quality Program and Tom Stossel, director of translational medicine at the Brigham & Women's Hospital, kicked off the discussion. Many pharmaceutical companies are affiliate members of MAHP, so participants included pharmaceutical folks as well as health plan medical staff.

What struck me most about the excellent discussion is how the absence of an overall budget for health care has tilted public discourse in a polarized black and white direction. Marcia Hams made a strong, thoughtful advocacy argument that pharmaceutical marketing activities contribute to increased costs and negative impacts on quality. Tom Stossel made a strong, thoughtful advocacy argument that pharmaceutical marketing activities contribute to decreased overall costs and quality improvements.

If we had an overall budget for our health system, or real budgets for components of the system, we'd be having a different set of discussions. Instead of arguing about whether industry influence on medical practice and health care costs is good or bad (it's both), we'd be discussing questions like whether a particular intervention created enough value to justify its use, and how its cost-effectiveness measured up against alternatives.

Many in the policy community argue that the U.S. population is unwilling to recognize and accept limits in health care. In my view, the scattered structure of our health system - most notably, the absence of overall budgets - has made it difficult for us to consider relative value, trade offs, and opportunity costs. By now we're habituated to not thinking about these questions, which makes us progressively immature as a body politic and vulnerable to nonsense like "death panels" and fear that the Affordable Care Act will lead to a government mandate that we all eat broccoli!

(This has been the longest time without a post since I started the blog almost five years ago. I've been unusually busy with teaching activities and a number of projects. It's good to be back!)

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Gay Liberation and Psychiatric Arrogance

Last month at the Lyric Stage in Boston I saw The Temperamentals, a docudrama about the founding of the Mattachine Society, the first sustained LGBT advocacy organization in the US. The program pointed me to a biography of Harry Hay (1912 - 2002), founder of the Society.

I was especially interested in Harry Hay's single encounter with psychiatry. Harry had been sexually (very) active since his teen years. He experienced no doubt about his sexual identity and wasn't conflicted about it, despite strong social stigma at the time. After his lone experience of heterosexual intercourse he blurted out - "I certainly hope I never go through that again!"

Harry was a passionate, romantic soul, given to infatuation and heartbreak. He was also a devoted member of the Communist Party. In his mid 20s he told his doctor about a recent breakup. The doctor referred him to a therapist. Harry told the therapist about his despair "in not being able to find a flower-faced boy who was a Marxist like me, and who would stand with me in the class struggle against oppression." The therapist suggested that Harry think about women: "Maybe instead of a girlish boy, you're looking for a boyish girl. Do you know one?" Harry did - Anita Platky, also a member of the Party.

But Harry worried as to whether he could sustain a physical relationship with a woman. The therapist assured him that he could. Harry reported to his biographer - "He told me that all I needed to do to change my orientation was to deliberately close one book and open another."

The official line of the Communist Party was that homosexuals (the word "gay" wasn't in use then) were excluded. It's unclear how much this policy represented homophobia and how much it reflected fear that gays and lesbians were vulnerable to blackmail at the time. (Most likely it was a combination.) Harry's devotion to the Party made heterosexual marriage desirable to him. He couldn't be an activist and leader in the Party if he remained unmarried.

Harry and Anita stayed married for 13 years, but Harry increasingly returned to covert gay relationships and finally to the founding of the Mattachine Society. When he ultimately left the marriage in 1951, Anita felt deeply betrayed.

The therapist's recommendation to Harry in 1938 was consistent with what I was taught as a psychiatry resident in the mid 1960s - that gay orientation was a "symptom" or a "disorder" that could be changed by therapy or willpower. There was no evidence for this view - it was purely ideological. It was an especially implausible recommendation to have made to Harry, given his unambiguous gay orientation. In retrospect, the mental health professions and the therapist Harry saw just one time were arrogant in regarding ideology as truth.

Harry's experience of marriage to a woman he cared about as a friend but couldn't embrace as a sexual partner convinced him that the LGBT community had to organize and advocate for human rights. It's an irony of history that the arrogance of his one-session therapist contributed to the gay liberation movement in a way that couldn't be appreciated at the time!

Saturday, April 28, 2012

"By Blood" by Ellen Ullman

I've just finished reading a remarkable novel: By Blood by Ellen Ullman.

I'd read in a review that the story is told by a disgraced professor who eavesdrops on a psychotherapy occurring in the adjacent office. How could I, after years of psychiatric practice, resist a story like that!

The professor/narrator, whose name we never learn, and whose sordid doings at the university he's been forced to leave we only get hints about, is immediately obsessed with the young lesbian, adopted patient and her German born therapist. To the narrator, being adopted means being free from blood ties to one's past. Since his ancestry is replete with suicides, the image of escape is appealing. But once the person he refers to as his "dear patient" begins to search for her birth mother, he becomes a detective, and ferrets out clues that he passes on to her, in the guise of the agency that handled her adoption. The complex story leads from San Francisco to Bergen-Belsen and Israel. I won't spoil the reading experience by giving too many details.

For me Ullman's novel created an experience that was common in clinical practice and, more broadly, life: a feeling that behind a surface that initially seems bland there's a fascinating, illuminating story to be found.

When Elvin Semrad, the training director in my residency was asked whether he didn't sometimes get bored with his patients, he said something like this:
No human being is boring. If we feel bored, one of two things is happening - either the patient is avoiding what's really bothering him, and the words are a cover, or the patient is talking about an issue that we haven't resolved for our self, and boredom is our defense.
Whenever I felt bored in clinical practice I applied Dr. Semrad's teaching - it always gave good guidance.

By Blood is about curiosity, and I'll bet that if you start it you'll find that it evokes such strong curiosity you won't be able to put it down. "Curiosity" is title of a 1999 essay in the Annals of Internal Medicine by Dr. Faith Fitzgerald that I admire and have often used in teaching. Dr. Fitzgerald was offended when patients were described as "uninteresting," and challenged the resident leading the team she was making rounds with to choose the least interesting patient on the ward:
He chose an old woman admitted out of compassion because she had been evicted from her apartment and had nowhere else to go. She had no real medical history but was simply suffering from the depredations of antiquity and abandonment. I led the protesting group of house staff to her bedside. She was monosyllabic in her responses and gave a history of no substantive content. Nothing, it seemed, had ever really happened to her. She had lived a singularly unexciting life as a hotel maid. She could not even (or would not) tell stories of famous people caught in her hotel in awkward situations. I was getting desperate; it did seem that this woman was truly uninteresting. Finally, I asked her how long she had lived in San Francisco.

“Years and years,” she said.

Was she here for the earthquake?

No, she came after.

Where did she come from?

Ireland.

When did she come?

1912.

Had she ever been to a hospital before?

Once.

How did that happen?

Well, she had broken her arm.

How had she broken her arm?

A trunk fell on it.

A trunk?

Yes.

What kind of trunk?

A steamer trunk.

How did that happen?

The boat lurched.

The boat?

The boat that was carrying her to America.

Why did the boat lurch?

It hit the iceberg.

Oh! What was the name of the boat?

The Titanic.

She had been a steerage passenger on the Titanic when it hit the iceberg. She was injured, made it to the lifeboats, and was taken to a clinic on landing, where her broken arm was set. She now was no longer boring and immediately became an object of immense interest to the local newspapers and television stations—and the house staff.
I'm writing about By Blood in an ethics blog because I believe the right kind of curiosity about our fellow human beings is the royal road to good ethics. Fancy words used in ethics teaching - "autonomy," "informed consent," "beneficence" and more - provide useful frameworks, but they don't provide the vivid human truth that empathic curiosity points us to.

(An excellent interview with the author can be found here. And an excellent review from the New Republic is here.)

Saturday, April 21, 2012

Returning to Practice After Loss of License

Two years ago I wrote about Dr. Brian Kwetkowski, a primary care physician in Rhode Island, who lost his license for having a sexual relationship with a patient. According to the Rhode Island Board of Medical Licensure and Discipline, Dr. Kwetkowski is a 1996 graduate of the New England College of Osteopathy, and is Board Certified in Family Medicine. The Board reported that three years prior to his voluntary surrender of his license, Dr. Kwetkowski commenced a sexual relationship with a 19 year old female patient.

The Board required Dr. Kwetkowski to "enter a treatment facility and complete all of the recommendations of the evaluators." Dr. Kwetkowski did this at the Acumen Institute, in Lawrence, Kansas. The clinical staff has impressive credentials. All had formerly been associated with the Meninger Clinic until the Clinic moved from Kansas to Texas in 2003. Here's how Acumen describes its program:
Embedded within all aspects of our individual and group treatment, education, and coaching processes is an emphasis on the components of professionalism, maintaining appropriate role functions, and high-achievement. We endeavor to help our clients to develop the insight and the skills they need to resolve work-related and personal difficulties and fashion life plans that foster integrity, authenticity, and physical and psychological well-being. Within an intensive day treatment/coaching process, our staff helps each physician to:


•Identify deficits in professionalism

•Recognize personal development needs and goals and develop an adaptive way to have those needs met

•Identify and adjust personality attributes that have led to self-defeating outcomes

•Monitor response to medication, if indicated

•Internalize new leadership and personal life skills sets

•Implement new skills that promote a team-based work environment

•Develop a leadership plan tailored to the client's particular strengths and career context
These are the right goals for physicians a licensure board sees as potentially capable of rehabilitation and return to practice.

I learned today from a reader's comment that on March 8, 2011, the Rhode Island Board of Medical Licensure and Discipline reinstated Dr. Kwetkowski's license. He must be monitored by the Rhode Island Physicians Health Committee for five years, continue in weekly psychotherapy, practice only in a group setting, be chaperoned with all female patients, and had to return to the Acumen Institute three times in 2011 for followup assessment, which included polygraph testing "to document the absence of boundary violations."

Many of Dr. Kwetkowski's former patients responded to my original post and described him as an outstanding physician. I assume from the Board's actions that his track record apart from the serious boundary violation must have been good, and that the violation was not part of a pattern carried out with other patients. I further assume that the Board believed that it was safe to allow him to return to practice under the specified conditions. If Dr. Kwetkowski continues to care for patients in the exemplary way former patients described and respects proper boundaries for the remainder of his career, the Board's decision will have been correct.

Thursday, April 19, 2012

The Ethics of Choosing Wisely and Practicing Efficiently

This month the American Board of Internal Medicine Foundation (ABIM) joined with nine medical specialty societies, each of which released a list of five tests, procedures or treatments whose use and clinical value were not supported by evidence, as determined by experts from the specialty.

This is a major step for the US health system. We've been phobic about engaging seriously with waste. In the 1990s we asked insurers to do the job, but physicians and patients pushed back against "managed care," and insurers backed off. Now we physicians ourselves are stepping forward. It's about time!

Among the 45 recommendations, the ones that are "absolute" should be relatively easy to discuss with patients, as in this example from cardiology:
Don’t obtain screening exercise electrocardiogram testing in individuals who are asymptomatic and at low risk for coronary heart disease. In asymptomatic individuals at low risk for coronary heart disease (10-year risk <10%) screening for coronary heart disease with exercise electrocardiography does not improve patient outcomes.
There's no waffling here - this form of screening "does not improve patient outcomes." If I were a cardiologist I would say that asking Medicare, Medicaid, or a private insurer to pay for the screening would be unethical. If it is known not to improve outcomes there's no justification for using shared health care funds to pay for it. And I'd feel fully comfortable looking my patient in the eye and explaining why I would not order the test.

The same is true for this "absolute" recommendation:
Don’t obtain imaging studies in patients with non-specific low back pain.
In patients with back pain that cannot be attributed to a specific disease or spinal abnormality following a history and physical examination (e.g., non-specific low back pain), imaging with plain radiography, computed tomography (CT) scan, or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) does not improve patient outcomes.
But some of the recommendations are "relative," not "absolute," as in these two examples:
Don’t obtain preoperative chest radiography in the absence of a clinical suspicion for intrathoracic pathology.
In the absence of cardiopulmonary symptoms, preoperative chest radiography rarely provides any meaningful changes in management or improved patient outcomes.
Don’t use cancer-directed therapy for solid tumor patients with the following characteristics: (a) low performance status (3 or 4), no benefit from prior evidence-based interventions, not (b) eligible for a clinical trial, and no strong evidence supporting the clinical value of further anticancer treatment.
Studies show that cancer directed treatments are likely to be ineffective for solid tumor patients who meet the above stated criteria...
Suppose a patient with a solid tumor that meets the specified criteria protested - "I understand that further chemotherapy is unlikely to be effective, but I want to try anything with the slightest chance of helping me. Your medical society is recommending rationing! That's not fair!"

The oncologist won't have an easy time responding. The patient is right - the medical society has made a rationing recommendation. In my view, this is a long overdo step forward out of the lala land of make believe infinite resources. But in our political culture, the word "rationing" is avoided as assiduously as the "f" word. Our reflex is to deny that rationing is occurring, not to discuss the rationale for why and how it is being done.

And with regard to the recommendation against a routine chest X-ray, it's only a matter of time until the evening news features a patient whose X-ray picked up an undiagnosed cancer, leading to cancellation of the scheduled surgery and removal of the cancer. The patient will tell us "the X-ray saved my life - are we going to let a rationing decision kill people just to save money?"

I hope the ABIM and the specialty societies are brave enough not to run for cover when the inevitable backlash occurs. They've taken a courageous step on behalf of the health of patients who could be harmed by interventions that wise clinical practice should avoid. And they've pushed us towards open engagement with the question of when interventions that "rarely" produce any benefit should be paid for our of shared insurance funds. We should thank the ABIM and the specialty societies for their contribution to healthier patients and a healthier society!

(Information about the ABIM's "Choosing Wisely" program can be found here.)




Monday, April 16, 2012

Making Doctors more Ethical

The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) has redesigned its Medical College Admission Test (MCAT) for the first time since 1991. For premeds, the MCAT is like the pearly gates - they have to pass through it to get to the promised land of medical school. It's more than 50 years since I took the MCAT, but as I wrote this paragraph I felt my pulse going up. Our innards don't forget major stressors from the past!

Starting in 2015, the MCAT will add a section on psychology and sociology and another on critical analysis, to the sections on the hard sciences and mathematics. The AAMC wants to send the message to premeds and colleges that medicine requires more than mastery of scientific knowledge. And they're right - taking good care of patients requires understanding the patient's psychology and social context, application of critical analysis to diagnosis and treatment planning, and the interpersonal skills for developing trusting relationships.

The MCAT section on psychology and sociology will be organized around five basic truths about human nature and society that the designers of the test call "foundational concepts":
  • Biological, psychological, and socio-cultural factors influence the ways that individuals perceive, think about, and react to the world.
  • Biological, psychological, and socio-cultural factors influence behavior and behavior change
  • Psychological, socio-cultural, and biological factors influence the way we think about ourselves and others.
  • Cultural and social differences influence well-being.
  • Social stratification and access to resources influence well-being.
The draft version of the new MCAT probes these basic truths with challenging questions. Some of them were tough to answer. I didn't get a perfect score.
At a welcoming event for first year Harvard Medical students in 1960, a distinguished scientist on the faculty asked me what I'd majored in at college. I told him - a combined major in philosophy and psychology. He responded - "philosophy and psychology - what are you doing in medical school?" 

The AAMC doesn't want that kind of "greeting" to happen in the future.

The AAMC is entirely right to extend the scope of what the MCAT examines. The new standards, however, are just a drop in the bucket for changing the culture of medicine. Doing well in psychology and sociology courses won't be hard for smart undergraduates. Course work matters,  but character can be refractory to book learning.

In a freshman philosophy course in college, the instructor asked "how many of you can refute Plato's argument for XYZ?" None of us raised our hand. "So am I right that you have all decided to change your lives in accord with XYZ?" Again, none of us raised our hand.

His point - the dissociation between what was on the page and what was in our hearts, was clear. In a similar vein, in the anatomy lab during my first year of medical school the instructor came to my table and asked our group about the course and branches of the femoral nerve (the major nerve going to the leg). Studious book learners that we were, we looked at the ceiling and tried to recall what we'd read in the anatomy text. The instructor suggested - "wouldn't it be better to look at the dissection you've just done?"

What premeds learn in social science courses is important, but what they learn from personal relationships, their jobs, teams, and volunteer activities has a deeper influence. I love leading a section of the first year Harvard Medical "Professionalism and Medical Ethics" course, but I think of it as trying to impart a framework that - with good luck and good mentoring - the students will be able to apply in their future clinical work. Albert Schweitzer taught that "Example is not the main thing in influencing others. It is the only thing." The example of what the AAMC is saying in its redesign of the MCAT is probably as important as what future students will learn in Psychology and Sociology 101!




Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Anne Sexton's Therapy Tapes

After arguing in a recent post that poet Anne Sexton's therapist did the right thing in releasing tapes of her therapy to Diane Middlebrook, Sexton's biographer, I read Middlebrook's biography itself. (It's a "good read," especially for anyone interested in the 1960s poetry scene.) I'm surprised that the biography didn't persuade all those who lambasted Dr. Martin Orne back in 1991 that he'd acted in accord with the guidance Sexton, who died of suicide on October 4, 1974, would almost certainly have given him.

Middlebrook describes how often people with mental health problems wrote to Sexton about how much her poetry meant to them. Sexton responded to every letter in a concerned, supportive manner. When she met she met with the young poet C.K. Williams, he was "surprised by how much she would talk about her therapy when our relationship was not very intimate. But  then, it wasn't a very intimate subject to her."

Sexton was fascinated by Williams's experience teaching a poetry workshop for psychiatric patients in Philadelphia.  In 1968-1969, she picked up on his idea and offered a weekly poetry workshop for patients at McLean Hospital. She worked hard at it. When a member of the workshop complained that Sexton was not being critical enough, Sexton responded:
"You are right. I don't like to discourage anyone at McLean. I feel that everyone has something to say and will perhaps, in time, have more important things to say. Poetry led me by the hand out of madness. I am hoping I can show others that route."
The strongest reason I could see for not releasing the tapes to Middlebrook is the fact that Sexton's niece and mother-in-law opposed it, feeling that revelation of the details of her desperate moods and compulsive sexuality was disturbing. They're right. It was a very disturbing life. But neither was in the role of executor - that was Sexton's older daughter Linda. And there's no reason to think that Sexton's self disclosure was intended to cause pain to those who were close to her.

Anne Sexton died in 1974. Martin Orne, who released the tapes, died in 2000. But the question of whether he did the right thing lives on. Having read the biography, I continue to believe that Orne was doing what his former patient would have wanted him to do.