Showing posts with label complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). Show all posts
Showing posts with label complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). Show all posts

Monday, July 23, 2018

Forest Bathing

For years I've enjoyed taking long walks in the woods. But it's only from reading a recent New York Times article that I learned I've been following the Japanese practice of shinrin yoku - "forest bathing."

There's nothing new about walking in the woods. Our ancestors spent their lives in forests. I assume many forest-dwelling genes are buried in our DNA. But as our species has become progressively more urbanized we spend most of our time indoors. A 2001 EPA survey reported that we Americans spend 87% of our waking time indoors, and another 6% in an enclosed vehicle!

In 1982 the Japanese Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries coined the term translated as "forest bathing" to describe the effort to imbibe what it saw as the healing power of nature by going into green areas with a mindful attitude. Since then, in the U.S., an "Association of Nature Forest Therapy" has trained and certified multiple cohorts of forest guides. A Google search shows that forest bathing is catching on as a commercial "back to nature" trend.

As an adolescent, Walden and Henry Beston's The Outermost House were among my favorite books. It seemed obvious that there was something very "natural" about being in "nature."

Three days ago the Journal of the American Medical Association published an important study demonstrating that creating green spaces of grass and trees on what had been garbage-strewn abandoned lots has a positive mental health effect on the neighborhood. This was a methodologically rigorous, randomized study that is likely to convince skeptics that there's more than sentimental anecdote behind the endorsement of time in the woods as a promoter of health and well-being.

In an aggressively capitalist society, it only takes a few nanoseconds for good ideas to become "monetized" and the focus for snake oil style hype. On the web I found vendors hinting that walking in the forest will combat cancer. But despite the hype surrounding the forest bathing concept, if I were still in clinical practice I would add spending time in "nature" as a recommendation to many of my patients.

Friday, May 27, 2016

An Ethical Perspective on Shared Medical Appointments

Stories about shared medical appointments keep popping up in the news, most recently in this New York Times article. The format involves bringing together a group of patients - as many as 15, but typically 8 - 12 - with a doctor or nurse practitioner, for a 90 minute discussion of shared medical problems, such as diabetes. Although group visits are not for everyone, the response of patients who participate and clinicians who lead the sessions are generally quite positive.

Group visits arose to promote efficiency. Although current discussions describe the format as an innovation developed in response to the parlous state of contemporary medicine, in 1905 Dr. Joseph Hersey Pratt, a Boston physician, began to lead "classes" for patients with tuberculosis. Pratt documented results that were as good as the best sanataria, but his method fell into oblivion.

In 1975 I had the privilege of starting a group visit program for patients with chronic psychiatric ailments at the Harvard Community Health Plan HMO . I conducted the group in collaboration with an excellent psychiatric nurse. I spoke with patients individually and to the group as a whole. If I wanted to recommend a medication to patient A, I often asked patient B, who was taking the medication, to talk with A about it. It was set up as a "drop in" group. Patients could come every week or just intermittently.

Physicians who lead shared medical appointments experience a different relationship with patients than in the 1:1 format. The group is more informal, and the physician often acts as a facilitator of patient-to-patient exchange, rather than as an authority. The framework tends to bring out the humanity of clinicians and patients. It's difficult for the leaders to be cold, detached or pompous.

I don't know how well the aspiration for efficiency holds up, but I do know - from my own experience and from the literature - that group visits encourage a holistic, humane way of relating between doctors and patients. The rationale for the format tends to be presented in an apologetic manner: the health system is in a mess/physicians are too harried to pay enough attention/you'll get to spend more time with your doctor in a group. These statements are true. But apology undersells the value of shared medical appointments. For patients with chronic conditions that must be managed over time, the group format can bring out a patient's own strengths and initiative and allow physicians to tap into their capacity to care in a down-to-earth human manner in new ways.

That's an ethical achievement, not just a matter of efficiency!

[To learn more about shared medical appointments, a Massachusetts General Hospital guide to conducting group visits is here,  a description of the group visit program at the Cleveland Clinic is here, and a VA guide to setting  up a group visit program for patients with diabetes is here. If you would like pdf versions of my articles about Pratt and about the HMO group program, send me your email address via the comment function.]

Monday, February 6, 2012

Complementary Medicine in Australia - an ethical analysis

400 scientists and doctors have attacked the 19 Australian universities that teach, or give degrees in, complementary and alternative medicine (CAM):
 Such courses involve so-called ‘complementary or alternative medicine’ masquerading as, and sitting side-by-side with, evidence-based health-related science courses. We take the view that those universities involved in teaching pseudoscience give such ideologies undeserved credibility, damage their academic standing and put the public at risk.
The controversy is half scientific, half ethical.

We health educators should be honest. A lot of medical and nursing care is based on evidence. That evidence, and the sciences that allow the evidence to be developed, should, and do, form the center of the curriculum.

But much of what we physicians and nurses do is based on belief and tradition. That doesn't mean we shouldn't do and teach these things. But we should be honest with ourselves and our students about when our practices aren't evidence based. Non-evidence based practice isn't limited to CAM!

Controversy over CAM isn't new. In the early 20th century organized medicine was horrified by the growth of Christian Science. Wise physicians recognized that the emergence of Christian Science reflected a sense that something was missing in "conventional" medicine. That hunger is still present. More than 1/3 of U.S. adults use "alternative" medicine techniques. I'm sure the same is true in Australia.

Gerald Caplan, my mentor in community psychiatry, taught me a valuable lesson about CAM. He experienced intermittent low back spasm, for which he had treatment with a chiropracter. Dr. Caplan told me:
The chiropracter takes low back pain seriously and lays on hands. The orthopedist is bored by it unless he can operate. I think chiropractic theory is nonsense, but chiropractic treatment gives me relief. Bringing relief is our goal in medicine.
There are three primary reasons why physicians should learn about CAM. (1) Many of our patients use CAM, and we should understand what they're doing in order to be able to advise. (2) We need to understand, from their perspectives, what felt needs CAM is addressing and what they hope to get from it. (3) Even if - like Gerald Caplan - we don't believe CAM practice is based on hard evidence and sound theory, we can sometimes learn from the way CAM practitioners carry out their practice.

Unfortunately, one of the Australian Universities manifested the same kind of arrogance that disturbs me when I see it in medicine. (I've interlaced my comments in bold italics.):
Students are taught the science-practitioner model and our aim is to produce graduates who are critical thinkers. [so far so good!] This enables them to distinguish between fad and genuine innovation in the discipline as practitioners, intelligent consumers of research and promoters of the scientific method. [even better!] A clear distinction is made in all of our courses between areas for which the evidence is clear and those in which the science has not caught up with accepted practice and where sufficient evidence has yet to be accumulated. [This is way off base. The speaker is assuming that "accepted practice" is based on science, and the science just hasn't "caught up" yet. That's religious faith, not critical thinking.]
(For previous posts about CAM, see here, here, and here. For the New York Times article from which I learned about Australia, see here.)

Monday, November 28, 2011

A Controversial Proposal about Complementary Medicine

A controversial proposal about complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) will be the hot item today and tomorrow at the annual meeting of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario. Since the College regulates medical practice in Ontario, this isn't a Mickey Mouse discussion!

The College felt it had to create a policy because patients in Canada, like those in the U.S., were voting with their feet - and money - for CAM:
In increasing numbers, patients are looking to complementary medicine for answers to complex medical problems, strategies for improved wellness, or relief from acute medical symptoms. Patients may seek advice or treatment from Ontario physicians, or from other health care providers.
The proposed policy explicitly recognizes a patient's right to decide on the course they want to follow:
Patients are entitled to make treatment decisions and to set health care goals that accord with their own wishes, values and beliefs. This includes decisions to pursue or to refuse treatment, whether the treatment is conventional, or is CAM.
In my psychiatric practice, I heard more than once from patients that their other physicians pooh-poohed psychiatric treatment, especially psychotherapy, with terms like "magic," "witch doctor" and "rent-a-friend." From that experience, I especially liked the way the Ontario College insists that physicians conduct themselves with civility:
The College expects physicians to respect patients' treatment goals and medical decisions, even those with which physicians may disagree. In discussing these matters with patients, physicians should always state their best professional opinion about the goal or decision, but must refrain from expressing personal, non-clinical judgements or comments...about the therapeutic options, or the patient's health care goals or preferences unless those are explicitly requested by the patient.
The fact that many physicians and physician organizations complained bitterly that this standard would "muzzle" them demonstrates the need for making civility and common courtesy an ethical expectation!

The Canadian medical community was especially vehement in its criticism of the way the original draft discussed standards of evidence for CAM. In the eyes of the critics, the College was setting a lower bar of evidence for CAM compared to allopathic medicine. Here's the key passage from the original draft:
Reasonable expectations of efficacy must be supported by sound evidence. The type of evidence required will depend on the nature of the therapeutic option in question, including, the risks posed to patients, and the cost of the therapy. Those options that pose greater risks than a comparable allopathic treatment or that will impose a financial burden, based on the patient’s socio-economic status, must be supported by evidence obtained through a randomized clinical trial that has been peer-reviewed.
To my reading, this statement was entirely reasonable. It's a small percentage of medical practice that's based on rigorous randomized controlled trials. The term "sound evidence" requires explication, but it's the best we can claim for much of what we physicians do. The wording of the revised proposal being discussed in Toronto today makes it clear that the same standard of evidence should be applied to "conventional" and "complementary" medicine. But to my reading it retains an appropriately skeptical view of just how solid the evidence is for what is conventionally done:
Any CAM therapeutic option that is recommended by physicians must be informed by evidence and science, and it must:

• Have a logical connection to the diagnosis reached;
• Have a reasonable expectation of remedying or alleviating the patient's health
condition or symptoms; and
• Possess a favourable risk/benefit ratio based on: the merits of the option, the potential interactions with other treatments the patient is receiving, the conventional therapeutic options available and other considerations the physician deems relevant.

Physicians must never recommend therapeutic options that have been proven to be ineffective through scientific study.
I applied these standards to myself with regard to my treatment many years ago of a patient with trichotillomania (compulsive hair pulling). The literature recommended medication and stated that hypnosis did not work. But my patient didn't want to take medication, and liked the concept of hypnosis, despite what the literature said. We agreed that it seemed relatively risk free, and tried it.

It worked. I didn't see the patient again until 20 years later, when the symptoms recurred. A brief repeat of the hypnosis did the job again. (For a more extensive discussion of the case, see here.) I believe the Ontario College would conclude that the treatment met their standards. I had done the hypnosis, but I hadn't recommended it!

If I were in Toronto today I'd vote to approve the College's proposal. Without demeaning "conventional" medicine it implicitly recognizes the degree to which conventional practice rests on uncertainties. And without using the term "placebo effect" it allows for the provision of interventions - "conventional" and "complementary" - that may well derive their efficacy from the placebo mechanism.

(The proposal being considered by the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons can be found on pages 248-275 of the agenda for today's meeting. If you're especially interested in the topic, you can read the original policy statement draft here. A summary of the Canadian Medical Association's criticism of the original draft is here.)

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

The Ethics of Using Placebos in Clinical Practice

The most interesting research study you may ever read about was published last month in PLoS - "Placebos without Deception: A Randomized Control Trial in Irritable Bowel Syndrome."

Placebos have been the focus of much attention in medical ethics. We know that placebos can produce positive effects in many conditions, but it has been believed that deceiving the patient was necessary for a placebo to be effective. Clinicians (and students in ethics classes) confronted what appeared to be a choice between helping patients feel, and be, healthier, and truthfulness in the clinical relationship.

Many years ago I was referred an elderly Russian woman who, after a severe stroke, was left with a severe anxiety state. None of the "conventional" interventions I tried helped her at all. At that point her daughter asked me to give her a placebo and to tell her that the placebo would help her. In as non-judgmental a way as I could muster I said "In the U.S. we believe we should be truthful with our patients and don't like to deceive them." The daughter replied - "You're being self-centered. That's your way. I'm recommending what we would do in Russia!"

I thought she had a point. I checked with a colleague who treated many Russian immigrants. He confirmed that his Russian patients saw benign deception as something good doctors would, and should, do.

I decided to do what the daughter had requested. The pharmacy my practice used was surprised to be asked about placebos, but could make one available. But at this point the family moved, so I didn't get to see if we could alleviate her symptoms with an impressive looking sugar pill.

Still longer ago, as a 25 year old medical intern I was, alas, much more cavalier. In my clinic I had a patient who was chronically agitated by what I thought were trivial matters. When my most likely inept efforts at counselling produced no results I gave her a bottle of brightly colored placebos I'd gotten from the pharmacy and told her they would calm her nerves. (I wish I could say I conducted a deep ethical analysis before going ahead, but that would be a deceptive claim.)

My patient did indeed experience reduced anxiety. To my surprise, her diabetes also came into better control. I've never doubted the power of the placebo effect since then.

In the project reported in PLoS, patients with IBS were invited to join a study in which they would receive "either placebo pills, which were like sugar pills which had been shown to have self-healing properties" or no treatment. Those who were randomized to the placebo group were told (1) the placebo effect is powerful, (2) the body can automatically respond to taking placebo pills like Pavlov's dogs who salivated when they heard a bell, (3) a positive attitude helps but is not necessary, and (4) taking the pills faithfully was critical.

You can guess where this is heading. Over the three week trial, symptoms and overall quality of life improved substantially more in the placebo group than in the control group. In the context of the study, deception wasn't necessary.

However well the findings hold up in the efforts at replication that are sure to follow, the study points in a clear clinical and ethical direction. Clinicians who (a) believe that placebos could help their patients, but (b) also believe that deliberate deception is to be avoided except in unusual circumstances, can (c) prescribe a placebo with a clear explanation of the kind given in the study.

I've always thought it was shortsighted to use the word "just" before the words "placebo effect." The placebo effect is powerful and real, whether it is mediated by mental state, endorphin secretion, or some other set of mechanisms. We don't say "it was just the surgery" when a patient's life has improved post-operatively. The word "just" suggests our dis-ease and ambivalence about use of placebos.

If we can harness the power of suggestion and the power of truthfulness at the same time, it will make for a real advance in clinical practice!

Sunday, September 20, 2009

Shamans, Placebos and Multicultural Ethics

Over coffee I read in this morning's New York Times about how Mercy Medical Center, an acute care hospital in Merced, California, allows Shamans to participate in the treatment of Hmong patients from Laos.

The Merced area has a large Hmong population (from Northern Laos), beautifully described in Anne Fadiman's superb book "The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and The Collision of Two Cultures." What's especially interesting is that Mercy Medical Center is part of Catholic Healthcare West, a faith-based system "committed to furthering the healing ministry of Jesus," as well as "to providing high-quality, affordable healthcare to the communities we serve."

It's easier for our scientifically-minded U.S. culture to recognize the importance of religion and magic in dealing with "foreign" cultures than with our own. In my own experience as a psychiatrist, and in my relatively limited interaction with other doctors as a patient, I've been aware of how much of what we do is anthropologically similar to what Shamans do.

When patients ask "so I have a chemical imbalance, right?" and I agree, our exchange has much in common with what is happening when a Hmong patient asks "so a spirit is causing my pain, right?" and the Shaman agrees. Whether or not a chemical imbalance or a spirit is responsible for the clinical state, applying a cognitive model the patient trusts in concert with a trusted healer can have a powerful impact.

In 1986 I made my first and thus-far only trip to China. On a train I conversed with a man who spoke English. I asked how he used "western" medicine compared to traditional Chinese medicine. His answer made excellent sense. "If I have a headache or pain in my back I go to a traditional Chinese healer. If I have pneumonia I go to a 'western' medicine doctor and get an antibiotic."

On returning to the U.S. I was referred a man who had recently arrived from Southeast Asia but who was ethnically Chinese. He had classical symptoms of major depression - depressed mood, suicidal thoughts, weight loss and sleep disturbance - for which antidepressant medication was (and is) the standard treatment in the U.S. He was dubious about trying the medication, so I wrote out my thoughts and encouraged him to discuss the treatment with his herbalist. The herbalist approved of my suggestion and in some weeks the depression was gone, presumably (but not necessarily) due to the medication.

A year later my patient returned and described what sounded like symptoms of erectile dysfunction. I began to ask the kinds of questions I would typically ask in that circumstance. My patient looked horrified at the direction the conversation was going, at which point I encouraged him to see his herbalist for the problem. A few years later I met him at the clinic carrying a baby. Presumably the herbs did the job!

Mercy Medical Center and Catholic Healthcare West are practicing admirable small 'c' Catholicism (in my dictionary "broad and comprehensive in interests, sympathies; liberal"). U.S. medicine needs to extend the same cultural sensitivity and anthropological sophistication to our own practices. We tend to use the term "placebo effect" disparagingly - "the Shaman's ritual is just a placebo effect." Each group takes its own beliefs as literally true and, ideally, acts like Mercy Medical Center with regard to the different beliefs held by others.

If we were more attuned to how much "evidence based" medical practice depends on the power of faith, magic, and the lowly placebo effect, we would be less inclined to flog patients with excessive technical interventions and readier to minister to them in a truly healing manner. When religious fundamentalists persist in using prayer as the only treatment for children with curable cancers we take them to court. But when medical fundamentalists persist in using one technical intervention after another rather than acknowledging that cure is not in the cards our insurance pays their fees.

Years ago a dear friend had come to the end of the available treatments for multiple myeloma and the disease was progressing. When she visited with her oncologist - a leader in technical medicine - he said "the best thing I can do for you now is to give you a hug," which he gave. I've used that as an example of ideal care with medical students.

Our health system can learn a useful lesson from my friend's oncologist and from Mercy Medical Center and Catholic Healthcare West!

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Should the NIH Alternative Medicine Center be Defunded?

I only became aware of the controversy about the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) from an article in this morning's Washington Post - "Critics Object to 'Pseudoscience' Center."

In 1992 Congress allocated $2 million to establish an Office of Alternative Medicine (OAM) at the National Institutes of Health "to investigate and evaluate promising unconventional medical practices." In 1998 NIH Director Dr. Harold Varmus proposed having all alternative medicine research done through the NIH institutes, with the OAM coordinating the process. Senator Tom Harkin (Iowa), who pushed for the founding of the OAM in 1992, now pushed through legislation that elevated its status to that of a Center (NCCAM). Current funding is approximately $120 million.

The current controversy was launched on January 15 by a posting on the website the Obama administration created during the transition to solicit ideas:
Biomedical research funding is falling because of the nation's budget problems, but biomedical research itself has never been more promising, with rapid progress being made on a host of diseases. Here's a way to increase the available funding to NIH without increasing the NIH budget: halt funding to NCCAM, the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. This Center was created not by scientists, who never thought it was a good idea, but by Congress, and specifically by just two Congressmen in the 1990's who believed in particular "alternative" (but scientifically dubious) treatments. Defunding NCCAM would save at least $225 million, possibly more.

...Any legitimate, promising medical treatment can be funded by one of the existing NIH Institutes. There's no need for a separate center for "alternative" therapies - but what has happened is that NCCAM has become a last refuge for poorly designed, unscientific studies that couldn't get funded through the normal peer-reviewed process.
Senator Harkin's comments, intended to support NCCAM, only make the Center look worse:
"One of the purposes when we drafted that legislation in 1992 . . . was to investigate and validate alternative approaches. Quite frankly, I must say it's fallen short. I think quite frankly that in this center, and previously in the office before it, most of its focus has been on disproving things, rather than seeking out and proving things."
The idea that the Center's role is to validate faith-based health beliefs shows a deep misunderstanding of science. If the Center has a role it is to test hypotheses, not to validate faith.

But the controversy over NCCAM isn't new. In the early 20th century organized medicine was horrified by the growth of Christian Science. Wise physicians recognized that the emergence of Christian Science reflected a sense that something was missing in "conventional" medicine. That hunger is still present. More than 1/3 of U.S. adults use "alternative" medicine techniques.

This enthusiasm proves nothing about effectiveness. But it does point to phenomena that warrant serious scientific study. Otherwise the field will be ceded to quacks and hucksters, in the tradition of Mark Twain's Duke and Dauphin, selling snake oil.

I don't have a sense of how well NCCAM has carried out its mission, but some of its goals seem right on target, as exemplified by:
* Identify the common and specific features of widely used mind-body medicine practices
* Determine the extent to which patient expectations prior to treatment and satisfaction following manipulative and body-based practices are related to objectively measured biological endpoints
* Enhance understanding of the social, cultural, and economic factors relating to the use of CAM.
But there is a worrisome ambiguity in other goals:
* Establish the efficacy of selected biologically based practices to maintain health, prevent disease, and treat conditions of public health importance
* Document the benefits of some CAM whole medical system treatments for selected health conditions
Is the aim here to evaluate whether specific widely used techniques are effective and provide benefit, or to "prove" that public beliefs in these techniques are indeed true?

If it's the latter, NCCAM should be defunded. But insofar as it undertakes serious evaluations of widely used techniques, and studies just what is happening when patients derive significant subjective benefit from techniques that are not validated in controlled trials, NCCAM will be making a worthwhile effort.

In voting with its money and time the public is saying it feels healed by alternative techniques. The mechanisms of healing are worthy of scientific study, just as the mechanisms of disease are.

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Complementary Medicine

A conversation with a colleague today got me thinking about how mainstream U.S. medicine ("western medicine," "allopathic medicine," "evidence-based medicine") relates to the wide range of complementary approaches.

Here's my reconstruction of what my colleague said:
"I had bad gastric reflux symptoms for a year. I tried changing my diet but that didn't do the job. My primary care doctor suggested Prilosec, but it didn't help. Then he suggested Prevacid. It cost me $50/month [this was the copayment at the pharmacy - when I checked on line today the lowest price for 30 30 mgm tablets was $189!] and I just didn't feel right on it. My joints hurt and I felt funny. He referred me to a GI specialist. She did an endoscopy. It showed some little growths in the stomach apparently caused by Prevacid. She suggested that I continue taking the medicine anyway.

But I'd had it with Prevacid, so I stopped it. I decided to look into alternative ("natural") approaches. Someone suggested that I try Probiotics. [Here's what the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine says about Probiotics: "Probiotics are live microorganisms (in most cases, bacteria) that are similar to beneficial microorganisms found in the human gut. They are also called "friendly bacteria" or "good bacteria." Probiotics are available to consumers mainly in the form of dietary supplements and foods."]

An Indian man at Whole Foods suggested what to try. It worked well. My reflux symptoms went away and the side effects of Prevacid were gone. I felt well.

I went back to the GI doctor for a follow up appointment. First I saw the nurse. I told her what I'd done. She said 'Lots of patients tell me that approach works for them.' But then the doctor came in and she stopped talking, as if she was saying something she wasn't supposed to say.

When I told the GI doctor about the Probiotics she said 'I've heard that it has helped some people, but we can only recommend what we know works.'"
I don't think this is an unusual vignette. Most physicians I know are not comfortable considering "alternative" approaches. I have no expertise in that area, but here's what I would have had the GI specialist say:
"I've heard the same thing from some other patients. From a scientific perspective we don't know whether this approach really works. But if you definitely feel you are doing better, I suggest that you continue what you're doing and monitor how you are. I also suggest that you go onto the web and see what is being said about Probiotics. Keep in mind that you can't believe everything you read. If the symptoms come back I'm happy to see you again. And if you're doing well - and I hope that's what will be happening - please give some follow up to your primary care doctor, just to make sure he knows how you are and what you've done for the symptoms."
"Evidence-based medicine" is a noble concept, but it's too much of a buzz word now - almost like a point of religious faith. Sometimes our evidence about what works is powerful, but often it's so-so at best. We should try to guide ourselves in accord with established facts, but we need to be more humble about the limits of our knowledge and more practical than my colleague's GI consultant was.

Since my first reading of Plato I've admired Socrates for his insistence that wisdom resides in acknowledging the depth of our ignorance. From my brief literature search today it looks as if evidence about the effectiveness of Probiotics for gastric reflux is somewhere between skimpy and nil. But my colleague's many months of experience with Prilosec and then Prevacid had produced no benefit, no matter what the "evidence" about statistical effectiveness might be.

A clinician schooled by Socrates would be able to acknowledge (a) the evidence we have favors medications like Prilosec and Prevacid, but (b) "evidence" isn't divine truth, and (c) thus far my colleague seemed to be doing decidedly better following a non-evidence-based approach so that (d) wisdom suggests continuing that approach and monitoring clinical status. The key evidence is how the individual human being is actually doing.

Sunday, December 2, 2007

Alternative Medicine & Hospital Ethics

In today's New York Times "The Ethicist" column, the always engaging Randy Cohen provides a model terse analysis of a complex organizational ethics question:

I work at a hospital where several nurses practice therapies like healing touch and therapeutic touch, said to adjust a patient’s energy field and thereby decrease pain and improve healing, although there is no significant evidence for this. If those nurses believe in these treatments, may they tell the patient they are effective? If the treatments provide merely a placebo effect, telling patients about this lack of evidence might undermine that benefit. Would that justify withholding the information?

Cohen starts by making the obvious point about informed consent: if the alternative treatments are offered, the nurses must inform the patients that the treatments are based on "non-standard" theories and have not been validated by research. Their personal conviction that the treatments work is just that -- personal conviction -- not evidence.

What I like most in Cohen's response is the way he thinks about individuals and the organization. Here is his concluding paragraph, with my comments in boldface:

What the nurses could do is explain that their techniques are unproved and unendorsed by the hospital (if this is the case; hospitals vary), offering patients, in effect, the sort of supplemental treatment available outside the hospital. But this approach is not without risk. A therapy provided in the hospital by its staff carries a sense of official approval, no matter what disclaimers are offered. [Cohen is right -- both the nurses as individuals and the hospital as an organizational entity have ethical obligations to the patient. The perspectives of both parties -- nurses and hospital -- must be presented to the patient.] In any case, these nurses must alert their colleagues and hospital administrators about such things. Both groups need to know how patients are being treated if they are to do their jobs well. [Cohen believes, correctly, that a well-functioning hospital can be a big tent. Patients can be offered science-based "western" care and tradition-based alternative "eastern" care if the nurses, their colleagues, and the hospital leadership, can allow their different perspectives to live side-by-side.]

Hospitals, like orchestras, benefit from having players with a wide range of talents and styles. Ethically excellent hospitals learn how to harness this variety on behalf of their patients. If in the future I were in a hospital for chemotherapy, I would hope to have "healing touch" available as well.

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Cheating on your doctor

An amusing and useful story on MSNBC starts: “After 15 pleasant years with the same person, Marcia David started seeing someone else. As several months of two-timing passed, she came clean: She told her doctor she’d been seeing a naturopathic physician on the side.”

The story came to me by email, accompanied by these comments: “Many people are seeking natural approaches to health care, but not everyone is comfortable with telling their traditional family doctor about it. Some patients hide their newfound approach to health care from their usual doctor but this secretive approach to health care can be harmful.”

For me the key part of this story is the source of the email. It came from Howard Trachtman, a mental health consumer activist in Massachusetts. Howard regularly sends emails to a distribution list of mental health professionals that includes the Commissioner of Mental Health and others in leadership positions.

Communicating about alternative medicine is an important piece of the effort to empower health consumers and patients. If we include prayer in our definition, two thirds of the U.S. adult population uses “alternative medicine.” When patients and physicians talk about alternative medicine we are not just exchanging nuggets of information -- we are acknowledging that as important as evidence-based medicine is, it is only part of what we do to improve our health when we are ailing.

The NIH Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine provides practical tools for physicians and patients to help them become more skillful at including alternative medicine in their conversations.

Experts in quality improvement like Jim Conway, vice president of the Institute for Healthcare Improvement, emphasize the importance of patient, family and advocate voice in making the health system better, safer, and fairer. We all need to improve our skills in talking straight with each other. This resolution isn't just politically correct goody-goodyism -- it is more evidence-based than many of the things we routinely do in health care.

So I thank Howard Trachtman and his colleagues for the email and for years of advocacy work!