U.S. health policy leaders are desperate. Despite innumerable studies, policy proposals and conferences, population health statistics continue to decline while health care costs continue to rise. Not an impressive result for all of that analysis!
One of the leading magic bullets proposed for the health system has been "consumer directed health care." The core idea is that if high deductibles put patients at risk for more of the cost of their care they will become (a) more active in promoting their own health and (b) more discerning "consumers" of health care. These are clearly desirable outcomes.
We know that "consumer directed health care" achieves two desirable outcomes. The cost to employers is reduced and the premium cost to individual enrollees is less than their cost would be for insurance without the deductibles. But what about the impact of deductibles on patients. Do they become more active in promoting their own health and sizing up the value of proposed health interventions?
A study from the University of Oregon published in American Journal of Managed Care suggests that the answer is - no.
The researchers surveyed 1616 employees at the start of their enrollment in plans with and without high deductibles and a year later. The key finding was that patients who were higher on a measure of "activation" (knowledge, skill, and confidence in managing one's own health and health care) became more active over the course of a year regardless of whether they were or were not in a "consumer directed health plan." Enrollment in a high deductible plan, however, did not prod patients to become more active.
In other words, in this group of insurees, the magic bullet of "skin in the game" did not transform otherwise passive patients into active "consumers" and self-managers.
Another article in the same issue studied a different approach to change. Instead of prodding patients with financial risk, on the assumption that they lacked "skin in the game," patients were treated as partners, and given the same information about clinical guidelines that their physicians received. Simply providing patients with clinically relevant information increased adherence to evidence based guidelines by 12/5%.
Wise clinicians will not be surprised by these findings. Health has intrinsic worth. It isn't a consumer item that requires financial penalties to make us care about it. Providing patients and clinicians with the same information at the same time is like well-timed therapy for a couple. It points in directions both want to go in.
Two studies aren't definitive, but they suggest a direction that builds on the core values of physicians and their patients. That seems promising!
Thursday, January 8, 2009
Tuesday, January 6, 2009
A Mild Wrist Slap for Pharma in India
Last month, before coming to India (where I am now) I wrote about the drug marketing scene. The posting gave a link to an article in the Times of India that suggested to me that the Indian media were on the trail of the Pharma-Medicine story that is currently exploding in the U.S.
In Delhi I met with Rema Nagarajan, the reporter who wrote the Times of India story. Rema is well-informed about developments in the U.S., such as medical schools banning all gifts to medical students, house officers and faculty. Yesterday she had a followup article in the Times of India that suggests that the exposure of excessive pharmaceutical company influence over medical practice is heating up in India. India does not have the same level of consumer advocacy and consumer protection that has been developed in the U.S., but India is on its way in that direction.
Here are excerpts from Rema Nagarajan's article:
Preaching doesn't create an ethical health system. Public understanding of what constitutes good health system ethics and public demand for accountable performance are required. The media and political leaders are key "educators" for the public. I'll try to glean more about the societal learning process in India while I'm here.
In Delhi I met with Rema Nagarajan, the reporter who wrote the Times of India story. Rema is well-informed about developments in the U.S., such as medical schools banning all gifts to medical students, house officers and faculty. Yesterday she had a followup article in the Times of India that suggests that the exposure of excessive pharmaceutical company influence over medical practice is heating up in India. India does not have the same level of consumer advocacy and consumer protection that has been developed in the U.S., but India is on its way in that direction.
Here are excerpts from Rema Nagarajan's article:
If you thought the government would crack the whip on pharmaceutical companies offering freebies to doctors for prescribing their products, think again. The department of pharmaceuticals has indeed taken note of the dubious practices reported by TOI on December 15, but in a surprisingly mild, almost apologetic tone.Establishing an ethical balance between medicine and commercialism in India will not be easy. Two very strong forces push against efforts to spotlight the problems and suggest solutions. Fist, there is tremendous trust in physicians, beyond what the profession deserves. (Rema quoted a Hindi saying in our discussion - "A doctor is like a God come down to earth.") Second, Pharma is a substantial component of the national thrust for rapid economic development. Successful enterprises aren't totally untouchable, but they are harder to tame than comparable enterprises in the U.S.
Joint secretary Devendra Chaudhury wrote to the various associations of drug manufacturers on December 18 citing the TOI report, but the letter suggests he would be "grateful" if the associations acted on suggestions made by the department.
...The mild tone is despite the fact that the December 18 letter admits: "The allegations cannot be in any way treated as ethical and something that could be endorsed by society in general. This also puts the pharma industry in a bad light since the enhanced promotional expenditure of the pharmaceutical companies result in enhanced market price of the drugs, which has to be borne by the consumer."
Yet, it says the department would be "grateful if you (pharma associations) could kindly take action" on its suggestions and also take steps to "prevent such perception in the mind of the public and other bodies to obviate misuse of promotional expenditure" and to kindly "prevent allegations as well as media reports on this subject as have appeared".
The joint secretary says in the letter that "the matter being extremely sensitive and of great public importance I am constrained to write to you". With such a mild and apologetic tone from the government it is anyone's guess whether the pharma industry would feel the need to take any action.
Both the Organisation of Pharmaceutical Associations of India (OPPI) and the Indian Drug Manufacturers Association (IDMA) had released their own codes of conduct at the beginning of 2007. However, there is no single code applicable to all drug manufacturers, a fact that the letter points out. But again, this is followed up by a gentle nudge: "You may like to consider having such a code for your members"...
Preaching doesn't create an ethical health system. Public understanding of what constitutes good health system ethics and public demand for accountable performance are required. The media and political leaders are key "educators" for the public. I'll try to glean more about the societal learning process in India while I'm here.
Thursday, January 1, 2009
Justice Cardozo on Trust and Professionalism
2008 overflowed with distressing stories about ethical lapses in medicine. In hope that the worst is over I wanted to open 2009 by discussing the best succinct statement I know about what being a trustworthy health professional entails.
In 1928 Justice Benjamin Cardozo was Chief Judge of the New York State Court of Appeals. (Four years later he was appointed to the Supreme Court.) On December 31, 1928 he published the opinion for Meinhard v Salmon. Here's the story.
In 1902 Walter J. Salmon obtained a twenty year lease on the Hotel Bristol on Fifth Avenue and 42nd street in New York, on the condition that he change it from a hotel to shops and offices. To finance the venture Salmon entered a joint venture with Morton H. Meinhard. Meinhard provided the money. Salmon managed the project.
Twenty years later, when the lease was about to run out, the property owner offered Salmon an opportunity to lease the current building plus a larger piece of property for a much bigger redevelopment project. Salmon took the lease without informing or involving Meinhard.
Meinhard sued to be let into the deal on the grounds that the opportunity to renew the lease belonged to the joint venture. Here's what Justice Cardozo wrote on behalf of the court:
Happy New Year!
In 1928 Justice Benjamin Cardozo was Chief Judge of the New York State Court of Appeals. (Four years later he was appointed to the Supreme Court.) On December 31, 1928 he published the opinion for Meinhard v Salmon. Here's the story.
In 1902 Walter J. Salmon obtained a twenty year lease on the Hotel Bristol on Fifth Avenue and 42nd street in New York, on the condition that he change it from a hotel to shops and offices. To finance the venture Salmon entered a joint venture with Morton H. Meinhard. Meinhard provided the money. Salmon managed the project.
Twenty years later, when the lease was about to run out, the property owner offered Salmon an opportunity to lease the current building plus a larger piece of property for a much bigger redevelopment project. Salmon took the lease without informing or involving Meinhard.
Meinhard sued to be let into the deal on the grounds that the opportunity to renew the lease belonged to the joint venture. Here's what Justice Cardozo wrote on behalf of the court:
Joint adventurers, like copartners, owe to one another...the duty of the finest loyalty. Many forms of conduct permissible in a workaday world for those acting at arm's length, are forbidden to those bound by fiduciary ties. A trustee is held to something stricter than the morals of the market place. Not honesty alone, but the punctilio of an honor the most sensitive, is then the standard of behavior.When stories emerged about unseemly financial ties between leading physicians and the pharmaceutical industry the standard defense was "I was honest in all that I did..." If we hear this lame self-justification again in 2009 our response should be - "that's not enough - as a health professional you are held to something stricter than the morals of the market place. Not honesty alone, but the punctilio of an honor the most sensitive, is the standard of behavior you must meet!"
As to this there has developed a tradition that is unbending and inveterate. Uncompromising rigidity has been the attitude of courts of equity when petitioned to undermine the rule of undivided loyalty...Only thus has the level of conduct for fiduciaries been kept at a level higher than that trodden by the crowd. It will not consciously be lowered by any judgment of this court. For [Salmon] and for those like him, the rule of undivided loyalty is relentless and supreme
Happy New Year!
Wednesday, December 31, 2008
A Mental Health Tragedy Revisited
On December 11 I did a post on the tragic story in which Marci Thibault, in a state of psychosis, took actions that led to her death and the death of her twin sister's two children.
Marci's sister and brother-in-law have a letter in today's Boston Globe. I quote it in full. It has a lot to teach us about tragedy, ethics and heroism:
In their letter to the Globe Danielle and Ken continue to teach us, this time about advocacy. For every tragic story like Danielle and Ken's, in which a normal appearing but deeply ill person like Danielle's sister Marci takes actions leading to terrible consequences, there are 10,000 stories about unjustified discrimination against people with a history of mental illness. And even if there is no simple guidance for police who are called to make evaluations of odd behavior, as happened when Marci was on her way to Danielle and Ken's home, the story they allowed the public to learn about will be used for police education all around the country.
If there's an award for ethical advocacy in mental health, I nominate Danielle and Ken Lambert!
Marci's sister and brother-in-law have a letter in today's Boston Globe. I quote it in full. It has a lot to teach us about tragedy, ethics and heroism:
Family coping with tragedy responds to its criticsMy first reactions to the letter were pain about the Lambert's suffering and fear that I might inadvertently have written something that added to their distress. On re-reading the December 11 post I was relieved to see that I had been very clear about my view of their conduct, as in the final sentence - "Danielle and Ken Lambert deserve admiration and respect for their efforts to transform private grief into public altruism."
December 31, 2008
WE ARE the parents whose two children were killed last January in traffic along with their mentally ill aunt. After being made aware of numerous online and in-print reader comments that were less than gracious, we wanted to clarify a few points and add to our public statements. Note that there is no pending lawsuit, and we are unsure whether there will be one. If there is ever one, and if there is any monetary judgment, proceeds would go directly toward the goals of our nonprofit, Keep Sound Minds.
We started this organization to improve awareness and education about mental illness to hopefully prevent another tragedy such as the one that befell our family. We will not personally profit as a result of this tragedy or any potential lawsuit.
An article was written about our story ("Finding words at last for an unspeakable loss," Dec. 7), and it seems many people are quick to crucify us as parents and people. We realized that was a possibility when we opened up to the public. That is unfortunate, but in our minds, the greater good of shining light on mental health issues far outweighs receiving backlash from people who don't know us.
We are similar to most of the readers of your paper. We loved and cared about our children deeply. They meant the world to us. If we believed Kaleigh and Shane would be in any danger that night, we never would have let them go. While we had some understanding of mental illness, we learned through the most painful way possible that we did not know everything. Our goal of Keep Sound Minds is to provide the public with better tools and knowledge to protect further innocent lives from being lost as a result of mental illness.
We pray that none of your readers will have to go through a similar tragedy, and we hope that people would be more understanding of the complexities of our case instead of immediately judging us as careless, self-centered people.
Ken and Danielle Lambert
Brentwood, N.H.
In their letter to the Globe Danielle and Ken continue to teach us, this time about advocacy. For every tragic story like Danielle and Ken's, in which a normal appearing but deeply ill person like Danielle's sister Marci takes actions leading to terrible consequences, there are 10,000 stories about unjustified discrimination against people with a history of mental illness. And even if there is no simple guidance for police who are called to make evaluations of odd behavior, as happened when Marci was on her way to Danielle and Ken's home, the story they allowed the public to learn about will be used for police education all around the country.
If there's an award for ethical advocacy in mental health, I nominate Danielle and Ken Lambert!
Saturday, December 27, 2008
The Sad Case of Nataline Sarkisyan Continues
Almost a year ago, in the context of the New Hampshire primary, I criticised John Edwards for politicizing the death of seventeen year old Nataline Sarkisyan, who experienced liver failure after a bone marrow transplant for leukemia, and whose insurer refused to cover liver transplantation. Here are the concluding paragraphs from that post:
Every health system has to set limits. This would be true even if Mother Theresa were the health czar. It is entirely reasonable to question the evidence basis for UCLA’s proposal or Cigna’s denial. Similarly, it is entirely reasonable to argue that the bar for evidence should be lower in last chance situations than in other domains of care. But Edwards, who I admire and largely agree with politically, does the public a disservice by presenting the denial as a moral crime.This morning the Associated Press reported that the Sarkisyan's attorney, Mark Garagos, is suing Cigna:
Edwards favors extending Medicare to a wider range of citizens. If he ends up as president, it will be interesting to see how he addresses the issue of limits. As Oregon Governor John Kitzhaber recognized 20 years ago, universal coverage is impossible without limits. No limits, no universality. It is that simple.
True leaders must be educators. Understanding the ethical necessity for limits is counter-intuitive for those who are not familiar with the health sector. Edwards may have done an effective piece of campaigning yesterday, but he was not providing the kind of ethical leadership that improvement of our health system requires.
This is especially unfortunate. Edwards is a superb communicator -- just the kind of voice we need to help us come to grips with the sad fact that health care limits, well set, are an ethical necessity, not a moral abomination.
Insurer Is Sued Over Liver TransplantMortality is sad, but the death of a seventeen year old is tragic. For any health system, deciding about coverage in a situation like that of Nataline Sarkisyan, is the most difficult challenge imaginable. While I have no expertise on liver transplantation for patients with leukemia, my impression is that a strong case can be made that not covering the transplant was a fair and justifiable decision. If the case comes to trial that's what the jury will be asked to decide. And if the verdict is appealed the Appellate Court(s) will have to address the issue the U.S. has tried so hard to avoid - rationing.
The family of a 17-year-old leukemia patient has sued the health insurance giant Cigna over her death in 2007 after the company initially refused to pay for a liver transplant.
The lawsuit, filed last week in Los Angeles County Superior Court by the family’s lawyer, Mark Geragos, accuses the company of breach of contract, unfair business practices and intentional infliction of emotional distress. It accuses Cigna of delaying and rejecting valid claims, which resulted in the wrongful death of the girl, Nataline Sarkisyan.
The insurer, based in Philadelphia, eventually approved the transplant after Nataline’s family held a rally outside its office in suburban Los Angeles. Nataline, however, died hours after the approval was secured.
Chris Curran, a spokesman for Cigna, said the company felt that the lawsuit was without merit. Mr. Curran said the company had volunteered to pay for the procedure out of its own pocket.
Friday, December 26, 2008
Psychiatric Ethics in Mumbai
Because of (a) my clinical specialty (psychiatry) and (b) the fact that I'll be spending time in Mumbai next month, the headline "Psychiatrists work overtime with traumatized in Mumbai" in yesterday's Boston Globe caught my eye.
Here's the gist of the story:
First, Dr. Mittal's comment to his patient - "I know you're going to need someone to exorcise this, but at the same time don't stop taking my medicine" - embodies cultural awareness at its best. He recognizes his patient's beliefs, sees how they can be integrated with the treatment he is recommending, and presents a respectful synthesis of traditional healing and allopathic medicine.
Second, when "hundreds of counseling professionals across India started an e-mail 'anger discussion group'" we're seeing the kind of self awareness and self discipline that all health care professionals should apply. Whatever area of health care we're in, our attitudes and values are part of the clinical equation, and we have to do all we can to make sure they don't distort the care we offer.
Finally, Dr. Shetty's citing of the Ramayana and Mahabharata places health care where it belongs - in the context of wider culture. Practicing evidence-based medicine is a necessary part of excellent practice, but isn't sufficient in itself.
Here's the gist of the story:
"Since the gruesome Mumbai terrorist attacks, mental health specialists have been in big demand here.For me, three aspects of the story exemplify admirable medical ethics.
But India, with 1.1 billion people, has only 4,000 psychiatrists, and efforts to provide adequate professional help for those traumatized by the rampage that left more than 170 dead and hundreds wounded is proving a daunting task.
Psychiatrists say it's not unusual to arrive at rural clinics and find 300 people waiting to see them. Each patient receives a scant few minutes of attention. Many give up and go in search of more traditional forms of assistance.
Evening "relaxation and breathing" workshops, for example, are being held in the immediate environs of the Chabad Jewish center that came under prolonged attack late last month and in other neighborhoods around Mumbai.
"We help ease people's tension through breathing techniques," said Ami Patel, an instructor with the Art of Living Foundation, which offers the sessions. "And people appreciate the feeling that someone cares."
...Mumbai psychiatrist Anukant Mittal is a case in point. He shuttles among city hospitals, suburban clinics, and primitive rural facilities, all part of a catchment area of 26 million people.
On any given day, Mittal sees patients ranging from chief executives of high-tech multinationals, who pay $50 per visit, to illiterate villagers wearing nothing but strips of cloth over their loins, and pay a subsidized 5-cent fee.
Rural residents sometimes turn instead to a shaman for help.
'You know very well they're going to go from your clinic to a witch doctor who will do black magic,' Mittal said. "So you have to say: 'I know you're going to need someone to exorcise this, but at the same time don't stop taking my medicine.'"
...Psychiatrists must grapple with their own anger, which can hamper their ability to help others. Recognizing this, hundreds of counseling professionals across India started an e-mail 'anger discussion group.'
'Psychiatrists are human, too, so we express our anger and try to heal ourselves,' said Harish Shetty, a social psychiatrist with Mumbai's Hiranandani Hospital.
'It's not always politically correct to admit anger, but in our epics, the Ramayana and Mahabharata, good kills evil,' Shetty said. 'It's part of our ethos.'"
First, Dr. Mittal's comment to his patient - "I know you're going to need someone to exorcise this, but at the same time don't stop taking my medicine" - embodies cultural awareness at its best. He recognizes his patient's beliefs, sees how they can be integrated with the treatment he is recommending, and presents a respectful synthesis of traditional healing and allopathic medicine.
Second, when "hundreds of counseling professionals across India started an e-mail 'anger discussion group'" we're seeing the kind of self awareness and self discipline that all health care professionals should apply. Whatever area of health care we're in, our attitudes and values are part of the clinical equation, and we have to do all we can to make sure they don't distort the care we offer.
Finally, Dr. Shetty's citing of the Ramayana and Mahabharata places health care where it belongs - in the context of wider culture. Practicing evidence-based medicine is a necessary part of excellent practice, but isn't sufficient in itself.
Tuesday, December 23, 2008
Hatred of Insurance Companies
The Obama transition team is sponsoring 4,200 house party-based grass roots discussions of health care in December. Today's New York Times reported on one of them.
In my work on health system ethics I've often invoked the need for a "societal learning curve" with regard to the health system. The Obama health care house parties will provide HHS Secretary Tom Daschle with a huge opportunity to see where the U.S. public is coming from in its understanding of the health system.
Here are some excerpts from the account of the health care house party, followed by my comments in italics. The report suggests just how much teaching and leadership we need from Secretary Daschle and President Obama:
In my work on health system ethics I've often invoked the need for a "societal learning curve" with regard to the health system. The Obama health care house parties will provide HHS Secretary Tom Daschle with a huge opportunity to see where the U.S. public is coming from in its understanding of the health system.
Here are some excerpts from the account of the health care house party, followed by my comments in italics. The report suggests just how much teaching and leadership we need from Secretary Daschle and President Obama:
"When a dozen consumers gathered over the weekend to discuss health care at the behest of President-elect Barack Obama, they quickly agreed on one point: they despise health insurance companies.If Secretary Daschle uses the health care house parties as an opportunity to refine his agenda for leadership they will provide valuable insight. But if the house parties are used to define the content of proposals we'll just continue down the same path of inexorable cost increases we are on now. Our political leaders - always excepting former Oregon Governor John Kitzhaber - haven't had the guts to help us face the need for limits and to begin to understand health care in a more nuanced way. It remains to be seen whether the new administration is up to the task.
They also agreed that health care was a right; that insurance should cover 'everything,' not just some services..."
I run the ethics program at Harvard Pilgrim Health Care. It's a not for profit health insurance company that insures a million people. For the past four years it has been rated #1 in member satisfaction and quality of care by U.S. News and World Report and the National Committee for Quality Assurance. I respect and admire the organization.
That said, health insurance companies are in an unenviable and perhaps impossible position, poised between (a) employers and government agencies frantic to control what they pay for health insurance (b) providers who are largely not held accountable for costs, (c) insurees who want "everything" covered, in a context of (d) severely limited public and political understanding of how health care really works.
"Dr. Lawrence M. Nelson, a scientist at the National Institutes of Health who emphasized that he was speaking as a private citizen, said: 'The incentives in the current health insurance system are upside down. The less care you provide, the bigger your profits.'"
In the 1990s, public policy asked insurers to mediate the gap between what payers wanted to pay, providers wanted to provide and patients wanted to receive by determining which proposed interventions were "medically necessary." That role wouldn't be easy for anyone - even Mother Theresa or Dr. Schweitzer. Insurance companies, especially for profit companies, were ultimately pilloried for setting limits. They've backed off from taking that role. Costs, of course, are skyrocketing again.
But Dr. Nelson's comment suggests just how tough a teaching job Secretary Daschle will face. Less care is often (a) as good as more care or (b) better. That's a counterintuitive lesson for much of the public. Entities that profit from providing less care aren't able to teach it. The Secretary has to find ways to help us learn.
The Obama transition team did not ask people how a new health care system should be financed, but several people here said that individuals and businesses should have to pay a small health care tax — some preferred to call it a “contribution” — so that everyone could be covered.
Not asking how the health system should be financed strikes me as a major error. There is no way we will come to grips with health care costs until we set a true budget for the health system. The idea that "small contributions" might get us to where we need to go suggests how much we are still living in lala land with regard to health care finances.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)