Wednesday, December 3, 2008

NICE is teaching the world about health care limits

Today's New York Times has a fascinating article about the firestorm triggered by NICE's decision not to cover Sutent, an cancer drug that may extend life of kidney cancer patients for 6 months, but at a cost of $54,000.

The article shows that NICE is the world's leading teacher about the ethical imperative for societies to set health care limits. I've quoted some excerpts from the article (in italics) followed by my comments.
"'Everybody should be allowed to have as much life as they can,' Joy Hardy [wife of Michael Hardy, who has kidney cancer] said...'It's hard to know that there is something out there that could help but they're saying you can't have it because of cost...What price is life?'"
Mrs. Hardy is profoundly right - deciding not to cover Sutent is a tragic choice. In terms of Albert Schweitzer's concept of reverence for life, the answer to the question "what price is life?" is - "it's priceless." But in economic terms, it's not.

Some years ago, Lester Thurow, then Dean of MIT's Sloan School of Management, suggested that we think about this kind of decision in terms of how much human labor the cost represents. $54,000 is a bit more than the average annual wage in the U.K. Asking "is it right to require John Doe to turn over his entire year's earnings to give Mr. Hardy a chance to live 6 more months?" feels significantly different than asking "should we allow a bureaucrat to sacrifice Mr. Hardy for $54,000?" Money isn't paper - it's ultimately human labor. We should have reverence for John Doe's life as well as Mr. Hardy's.
"Even in the United States, rising costs have led some in Congress to propose an institute that would compare the effectiveness of new medical technologies, although the proposals so far would not allow for price considerations...the idea of using price to determine which drugs or devices Medicare or Medicaid provides has provoked fierce protests."
The idea that we would forbid our government to consider cost - in other words, say that even if 100 or 1,000 John Does had to sacrifice their entire annual income they would have to do so to provide a chance for 6 more months of life - is so preposterous that it calls to mind Schopenhauer's famous comment about a philosophical assertion he found equally preposterous: "As a serious conviction it could be found only in a madhouse; as such it would then need not so much a refutation as a cure."

With regard to our public discourse about health policy, the U.S. is indeed a madhouse!
Robert Goldberg, vice president of the Center for Medicine in the Public Interest, an advocacy group financed by drug makers, likened Dr. Rawlins (director of NICE) and his institute to terrorists..."
This kind of Karl Rove take-no-prisoners rhetoric from a well paid PhRMA shill shows what NICE and its leadership is up against. I hope Michael Rawlins has a thick skin and a good sense of humor.
"Dr. Rawlins said he was frustrated that his institute had been censured instead of the drug company executives who set sky-high prices."
He's right to be frustrated!

Anyone who has brought up children knows how difficult it is to teach about limits and sharing. It takes patience, firmness, love and understanding the cost to the child of not learning. Children don't thank us. Like the hypocritically named "Center for Medicine in the Public Interest" they call us the equivalent of terrorists.

NICE is the kind of teacher the developed world - especially the U.S. - needs. Let's hope Michael Rawlins and his colleagues can keep up the good work!

Monday, December 1, 2008

Shared Medical Appointments - a Clinical and Ethical Innovation

Yesterday's Boston Globe had a fascinating article about shared medical appointments at Harvard Vanguard Medical Associates (HVMA), the group I practiced with for 32 years before retiring from clinical practice last year.

As implemented at HVMA and the Cleveland Clinic, shared medical appointments are 90 minute visits with one's own physician along with perhaps 8 - 10 other patients (see here for HVMA and here for the Cleveland Clinic). In shared appointments physicians do what they would do in a typical 15 minute visit - listen to the patient's story, ask questions, do the necessary physical examination, order tests and prescribe medications. (The intimate components of the physical exam are done outside of the group.)

The literature about shared appointments emphasizes productivity gains, improvement in access, and patient and physician satisfaction with the format. But from historical research I did on an earlier version of the shared appointment and my own experience with a related format in psychiatry, I believe there is an ethical or even spiritual dimension as well.

In 1905 Dr. Joseph Hersey Pratt, then at the Massachusetts General Hospital and later at the New England Medical Center, began to hold what he called the "tuberculosis class" at the Emmanuel Church in Boston. Pratt thought of the class as an efficient way of encouraging patients to follow a rigidly defined regimen of out-of-doors rest, the only treatment for TB at the time. Patients were directed to spend day and night in tents erected on the roofs and balconies of Boston tenements. A "friendly visitor," the prototype of the medical social worker - made regular visits to the home to provide supervision and support, and to assist the family in making the needed practical arrangements. A subsidy provided by Dr. Elwood Worcester, rector of the Emmanuel Church, paid the salary of the friendly visitor and aided in purchasing tents, blankets and other necessities. Pratt ran the class for 18 years. His results with poor patients from Boston appeared to be similar to the results achieved at the best sanataria.

In 1975 I had the privilige of starting an outpatient program for patients with chronic mental illness at the Harvard Community Health Plan (which later became Harvard Vanguard Medical Associates). The medical literature suggested that group-based programs were as effective as individual appointments (see here), so with the same productivity rationale we established a "continuing care group." The group, staffed by a psychiatrist and a psychiatric nurse met weekly, with 5 - 20 patients attending. We met for 90 minutes and discussed medications, managing symptoms, and life.

The group format was indeed efficient. But over time I observed that for many of the patients, as well as for myself, it was more than that. A closeness and sense of shared humanity gradually emerged. It helped patients see themselves as people with illnesses, not as "schizophrenics" and "manic depressives." People were able to help and support each other. Although I had to work hard at the meetings I found the rich human exchange exhilarating and deeply rewarding. It was a thoroughly secular exchange, but I believe a cultural anthropologist would have seen the group as having many elements in common with religious settings.

When I went to the Harvard Vanguard website I saw that my own primary care physician is among those who are offering shared medical appointments. I'm happiest when I have no need to see a health professional, but when I do I look forward to experiencing the format from the patient's perspective!

(The Boston Globe article gives access to a short video clip of a shared medical appointment, with background comments by Dr. Gene Lindsey, who'se leading the shared appointment. I encourage readers to make a two minute investment to watch the video - it's very informative.)

Thursday, November 27, 2008

More About the "Engage with Grace" Project

Yesterday I joined with other bloggers in a "blog rally" to (a) encourage ourselves and our readers to talk with those we are closest to about our wishes for end of life care and (b) to present a simple tool that could facilitate these discussions.

I learned from yesterday's Boston Globe that I'd gotten the story of the Engage with Grace project wrong in an important way. When Rosaria Vandenberg was close to the end of her life the hospital recommended that she stay. Although her brother did not know what Rosaria's wishes would have been - they hadn't had the kind of conversation Engage with Grace encourages - he took her home. Her two year old daughter, who had been afraid to touch her in the hospital, snuggled up to her in bed at home. Rosaria, opened her eyes for the first time in a week and gazed at her daughter. She died peacefully the next night at home.

Rosaria's family family felt it had made the right decision bringing her home, but wished they had talked openly with Rosaria about the values that were important for making the decision. Alexandra Drane, her sister-in-law, launched the Engage with Grace website to encourage others to have the kinds of conversations they wished they had had with Rosaria.

So many contributions to health care ethics come from individuals and families who learn deep lessons from their encounters with illness and mortality! These are gifts we can be thankful for.

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

A Tool for Discussing Wishes for End of Life Care

Paul Levy, President and CEO of the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center and author of the superb "Running a Hospital" blog, told me about Engage with Grace, a program that offers a simple and powerful tool for talking with those we love about our own end of life care wishes.

The website tells a moving story about Rosaria Vandenberg, a 32 year old woman who died from a malignant glioma, the same cancer that Senator Kennedy has. In light of Rosaria's wishes, the family helped her die at home, which allowed important loving exchanges with her two year old daughter.

We make choices throughout our lives - where we want to live, what types of activities will fill our days, with whom we spend our time. These choices are often a balance between our desires and our means, but at the end of the day, they are decisions made with intent. But when it comes to how we want to be treated at the end our lives, often we don't express our intent or tell our loved ones about it.

This has real consequences. 73% of Americans would prefer to die at home, but up to 50% die in hospital. More than 80% of Californians say their loved ones "know exactly" or have a "good idea" of what their wishes would be if they were in a persistent coma, but only 50% say they've talked to them about their preferences.

But our end of life experiences are about a lot more than statistics. They're about all of us. So the first thing we need to do is start talking.

The Engage with Grace "One Slide Project" was designed with one simple goal: to help get the conversation about end of life experience started. The idea is simple: create a tool to help get people talking. The tool is a single slide, with just five questions on it. Five questions designed to help get us talking with each other, with our loved ones, about our preferences. A group of like-minded bloggers are asking people to share this one slide wherever and whenever they can - at a presentation, at dinner, at their book club.

Just One Slide, just five questions.

Lets start a global discussion that, until now, most of us haven't had.

We are encouraging readers to download the slide and share it at any opportunity - with colleagues, family, friends. Think of the slide as currency and donate just two minutes whenever you can. We should all commit to being able to answer these five questions about end of life experience for ourselves and for our loved ones and to helping others do the same.

Let's start a viral movement driven by the change we as individuals can effect...and the incredibly positive impact we could have collectively. Help ensure that all of us - and the people we care for - can end our lives in the same purposeful way we live them.

Just One Slide, just one goal. Think of the enormous difference we can make together.

(This post draws on material written by Alexandra Drane and the Engage With Grace team.)

Monday, November 24, 2008

Coming Soon - An Overdue Debate About Free Market Health Care

Today I learned that PhRMA, the pharmaceutical lobbying group, is about to launch a multimillion dollar PR campaign on behalf of free-market health care (see here). Television ads are scheduled to appear soon. (I'm not much of a TV watcher, so if the campaign has already started, I haven't seen the ads.)

PhRMA has reason to be concerned. The fact that Medicare Part D forbids Medicare to bargain over drug prices got lots of negative attention during the campaign. That issue, along with the latest analysis of private Medicare health insurance plans, which reaffirms concern that the Bush administration's effort to privatize Medicare - especially the private fee-for-service plans - may be adding cost without adding benefit (see here), make it likely that the Obama administration will be taking a very hard look at the U.S. health system's reliance on free-market mechanisms.

The debate is not likely to line up as "conservative business" against "liberal government." Businesses like PhRMA and device manufacturers that sell health care services will line up on behalf of the "free market." (I put the term into quotes because the market is obviously not free, as in the policy decision not to allow Medicare to bargain over drug prices!) But businesses that buy health services for their employees may well line up in favor of new forms of regulation. Some businesses may lobby to bring the U.S. system of employer-based health insurance to an end.

My strongest hope is that debate about the health system becomes more evidence-based. Since the Reagan administration U.S. political dialogue about health has been dominated by free market theology - a faith-based belief that a "free market" will by divine ordination drive improvements in value and cost as it does for manufactured goods. But the pendulum is swinging. Less than a month ago former Federal Reserve chair Alan Greenspan, a faith-leader for "free markets," acknowledged with "shock" that his faith that markets would regulate themselves to serve the public good was "flawed."

As I wrote the previous paragraph lines from Matthew Arnold's poem "Dover Beach" popped into my mind:

The Sea of Faith
Was once, too, at the full, and round earth's shore
Lay like the folds of a bright girdle furled.
But now I only hear
Its melancholy, long, withdrawing roar,
Retreating, to the breath
Of the night-wind, down the vast edges drear
And naked shingles of the world.
The global economic crisis appears to be prodding the sea of "free market" faith into retreat. We in the U.S., who have guided our health system by that faith for 30 years, are in for an interesting ride!

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Hospital Branding, Money, and Ethics

A recent article by the Boston Globe investigative "Spotlight Team" about the differential payments Partners Health Care receives ("A Healthcare System Badly Out Of Balance") has the Massachusetts health policy community in an uproar.

The gist of the article is that Partners hospitals (most notably Brigham and Women's and Massachusetts General) and physicians are paid 15% - 45% more for treatment not demonstrably better than other facilities provide. Since (a) Massachusetts, like other states, is choking on high health care costs and (b) hospital and physician billing accounts for more than 85% of insurance costs, the story is causing waves.

What struck me most about the article is how much investigation was required for an area of public interest that should be transparent. The Spotlight Team had to rely on private insurance data revealed by one or a series of Deep Throat sources. Although the Massachusetts Health Care Reform law created a Quality and Cost Council, because of technical difficulties and controversy about the quality of the data there have thus far been no reports.

With a new administration coming to Washington in two months we will soon see a new level of challenge to our faith-based reliance on market forces to improve health care quality and cost. Less than a month ago former Federal Reserve chair Alan Greenspan acknowledged "shock" that his faith that market self-regulation would serve the public good was "flawed." Proponents of giving market mechanisms more time to control runaway health spending will have to produce evidence for the likelihood of success rather than simply invoking the sacred truths of ideology.

The U.S. has thus far been reluctant to venture far into tiered networks of hospitals and physicians. It's technically difficult to assess quality and efficiency. But we haven't been reluctant to transfer financial risk to individual patients in the form of high deductibles, asking them to do what we typically ask health plans, Medicare and Medicaid not to do!

Between the economic crisis and heightened skepticism about market solutions for the health care system we can expect to see a mixture of (a) an accelerated, last ditch effort to use market mechanisms like tiered insurance networks in which patients have access to all providers but pay much more for those judged to be lower in quality and efficiency and (b) heightened regulation, including the possibility of moving to a single national insurance plan.

Let's hope for more thoughtful and in-depth deliberation about health policy choices than we have seen for the last eight years.

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

Self-Insured Employers and Medical Ethics

This is the annual open enrollment time at many employers. (I have to make my own insurance choices for next year by Friday.)

In the past, employers - especially large ones - have offered a wide array of health insurance choices.

That's changing fast. Many companies, including large ones like Nissan and Delta Airlines, are offering only high-deductible plans to their employees.

According to the benefits director at Nissan the high-deductible plans are “aimed at getting people to focus on their health...when you are spending your own money...you are more careful in the way you spend it.” Common sense economics suggests this is true. Notice that no reference is made to how the careful spending will be conducted and what the potential clinical impacts might be.

The Delta spokesperson dips into wishful thinking: “We felt it was important to offer a plan that encourages participants to manage their health care and maintain their health and enables them to get the most out of their health care dollar. We find that when people get engaged in their health care they generally get healthier.”

Insofar as companies assume that financial risk alone will transform employees into discerning "consumers" of health care I believe they are living in la-la land. For urgent treatment, like hospital care or cancer chemotherapy, "patients" will not morph into "consumers" and shop around. And for the entirely valid domain of optional choices - whether to do a non-emergency MRI, or whether to choose a branded drug rather than a generic - good information on cost and quality is all too often lacking.

But as I've been thinking (and writing) recently, self-insured employers can make a significant contribution to public understanding about health care dynamics if they capitalize on the degree to which employees and management have a shared interest in getting a grip on costs.

If I ran a small self-insured business or was benefits director at a large one I'd meet with employees (in person or electronically, depending on logistics) way before the open enrollment period and put out all the facts I had about insurance costs and their impact on wages. I'd bring in someone who could facilitate deliberation about alternative strategies for bending the cost trend. And, if possible, I'd bring in a wise and respected local physician to educate the group about the areas of medicine that would benefit from discerning consumerism on the part of patients. My ultimate aim would be to engage employees and management in thinking about the trade offs cost containment requires.

My guess is that a robust workplace process would produce creative new ideas about health insurance processes, the same way quality circles, which started in Japan almost 50 years ago, have produced creative new ideas about manufacturing processes.

It's only a matter of time before multispecialty medical groups go to self-insured companies to propose "deals" akin to the original HMO concept, in which a medical group takes resonsibility for care of a population at a guaranteed price. If the employees looked over the proposal, considered the benefits (presumably good care at a better price) and trade-offs (use of a limited network) this idea, and others that are just being thought of, like choosing to build medical tourism into the plan, will come to the fore.

This kind of front line activity will not transform the broken U.S. health "system." But efforts at large scale transformation have a habit of crashing and burning. And even if the time becomes propitious for system-wide change, the more we as a population have deliberated about health care choices the way I envision happening in self-insured employers, the more able we'll be at handling systemic change.

(For additional information, see this excellent New York Times article - "Employers Offer Workers Fewer Health Care Plans.")